Tuesday, August 13, 2013

Jeannette Rankin

For this post, I'd like to talk about Jeannette Rankin, and the effect she had on Montana's history. The thing is, while Rankin became the first female member of Congress in the united states, this happened right at the onset of World War One. Montana at the time was very much pro war, and Miss Rankin was a pacifist. In fact, support for the war was so strong it was reaching levels of hyper-patriotism.

Coming from a state that contributed 25% more men to World War 1 than any other state in the union, becoming the only member of congress to vote against declaring war on Japan did not help her popularity.

Rankin believed that her work for the women's suffrage movement was similar to her pacifistic foreign policy. According to Rankin, the corruption and dysfunction that she saw in the government of the time was a direct result of the lack of feminine participation. She believed that women were better at keeping the peace, and wasn't afraid to make her position known. 


In 1917, Rankin attempted to intervene in the Speculator Mine disaster in Butte, which left 168 miners dead, and lead to a massive protest strike. Her decisions were so in question, though, that the mining companies would not meet with her, and her legislation fell through. 



Rankin was not re-elected the next term. 



She would not be re-elected to congress until 1940, which was interesting considering the fire her actions drew in World War 1. She again became the only woman to vote against going to war after the bombing of pearl harbor. In fact, the backlash was so harsh, Rankin was followed from the building by a mob, and had to hide in a phone booth until congressional security could find her. 



While Jeannette Rankin was the subject of endless controversy in her life, she stood up and did what she thought was right, no matter what her critics said. The question remains, as a representative of her state, did she do the right thing? 



Jeanette Rankin did what she thought was right. What she decided was best for her. I applaud her for standing up for her rights, and for being strong enough to hold her ground in the face of adversary, but she wasn't elected to congress to do what she thought was right. 



The point of a Congressional representative is to convey the wishes of the people, and Miss. Rankin failed to do that. When roughly ninety percent of the population she was speaking for wanted one thing, how did she justify voting for the opposite? 



The point, I suppose, is that it's hardly ever clear which way is right. Despite all the reasons I think what Mrs. Rankin did was right thing done for the right reasons, in this situation, I think she was wrong. 


Montana is a great place to visit, but an even better place to live. To learn more about becoming a part of the Montana Experience, contact Tom Clark (406) 581 2829, drop me an e-mail at tom@realestator.net, or visit my site: http://tomsclark.yourkwagent.com/atj/user/HomePageGetAction.do

Need something to do in Bozeman? Check out http://realestator.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Death Tax



For American farmers and ranchers, the death of a family member could also mean the loss of their livelihood. Because of the federal estate tax, often called the “death tax,” many ranching families are facing taxes which a great number of them cannot afford. Too many ranches have already fallen victim, so understanding the tax and planning accordingly is more important than ever.



According to the IRS, the federal estate tax is “a tax on your right to transfer property at your death”. This means that upon death, all of a person’s gross estate can be taxed at a predetermined rate, and the sum must be paid within 9 months. Unfortunately, this is often a price that beneficiaries can’t afford, and they are forced to sell off assets in order to pay the government.




The California Cattlemen’s Association. is working with others in an effort to have the death tax completely repealed, so that ranchers can safely keep their operations in their families. The current tax code allows for a $5 million dollar tax exemption with a 35% tax rate. This is favorable to those in the agricultural community because it allows for smaller family-run ranches to enjoy large savings after transition.



“The current tax law was set to expire in 2012, but was extended for a year. The law will revert to its 2001 levels at the end of the year. That’s a $1 million exemption with a 55% tax rate.”


This is especially troubling because the National Cattlemen’s Beef Association (NCBA) reports that anywhere from 96% to 98% of American ranches are family-owned. If the tax laws do revert, it could spell ruin for many of those operations.




Another problem ranchers face when planning transition is that the IRS calculates the gross estate by adding together all the deceased’s assets. This includes a person’s savings, insurance, property, investments, and other interests. Oftentimes this can lead to a family being burdened with a large tax bill based on their gross estate that doesn’t match up to their actual income.


One Man recommends starting the planning process as soon as the next generation reaches an age where transition would be viable. He also sees benefit in seeking tax protection by incorporating family operations. Entities such as Limited Liability Companies (LLCs) and S Corporations, and practices such as lifetime gifting can help save families from impossible debts. But White urges caution, and encourages people to seek professional help first.




One of White’s clients did just that when attempting to tackle the transition process. One of White’s clients in Oklahoma was faced with the task of organizing a transition after the death of his mother. The fellows grandfather started their family ranch in 1984. It consisted of 20,000 acres on which his family grew wheat and ran a cattle operation. Upon his grandfather’s death, the ranch was split up among his surviving family. The client’s share of the original ranch was then passed on to him after his mother passed away. At this point, the client reached out to Derrel White in order to sort through the resulting legal issues.






“[The estate taxes] were the most difficult part of the whole deal. It took a lot of time to sort through.“



Fortunately, the federal tax code provides significant relief for family-owned businesses, such as farms and ranches, according to Brooks Paley, J.D., LL.M., a Los Angeles-based attorney who specializes in estate and gift tax planning. “In fact, Congress does not want to force family-owned businesses to liquidate their assets to pay their estate tax.” Mr. Paley points out that, if the value in a closely held business exceeds 35 percent of the adjusted gross estate, an election may be made under Section 6166 of the Internal Revenue Code to defer payment of the estate tax for up to five years at a substantially reduced interest rate; and then the tax due may be paid off in installments over the following 10 years.


Mr. Paley asserts, “Consider making annual exclusion gifts to the next generation, which may be further leveraged if a qualified appraisal supports taking valuation discounts on transferred shares in a family limited partnership or family limited liability company. Also, assets such as life insurance would not be included in one’s taxable estate if the policies were transferred to an irrevocable life insurance trust, provided that the insured did not possess any ‘incidents of ownership’ within three years of his or her death.”




Finally, he points out that, “Members of Congress have a vested interested in not allowing the lower estate and gift exemption amount and the higher tax rate of 2001 to come back into effect. Nonetheless, because each individual may make cumulative lifetime gifts of up to $5 million under current law, which may or may not change after next year, anyone facing a potential estate tax should at least have a conversation with a knowledgeable tax-planning attorney while there is still time to act.”




Montana is a great place to visit, but an even better place to live. To learn more about becoming a part of the Montana Experience, contact Tom Clark (406) 581 2829, drop me an e-mail at tom@realestator.net, or visit my site: http://tomsclark.yourkwagent.com/atj/user/HomePageGetAction.do




Want to learn more about Ranching in Montana? Check out http://ranchinrevolution.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, June 25, 2013

Homesteads in Dillon

Clyde Hunter Smith was born in 1884 to a large Scottish/Irish farming family. Being from a family like that, he was well aware that he would never be able to have his own land, and so he packed his things, got on a train, and left for Montana. Over the next twenty four years, he gained a reputation for developing the best stock and draft horses in Montana.

In 1908 his work paid off. He homesteaded near Axes Canyon southeast of Dillon Montana, and turned it from a 320 acre homestead into a 5,000 acre ranch. This ranch was where he would eventually marry his childhood sweetheart, Madge Suzanna Ray.


Madge Suzanna Ray helped Clyde Smith raise eight children, countless cattle, horses, and crops. They were known to  Together the family weathered the depression, and came out stronger for it. They were well known for having the best Herefords in the united states. Smith remained a working cowboy to his dying day, and his family still lives on the ranch outside of Dillon, Montana.

Montana is a great place to visit, but an even better place to live. To learn more about becoming a part of the Montana Experience, contact Tom Clark (406) 581 2829, drop me an e-mail at tom@realestator.net, or visit my site: http://tomsclark.yourkwagent.com/atj/user/HomePageGetAction.do

Need something to do in Bozeman? Check out http://realestator.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, June 4, 2013

Montana's First Rancher

Ranching has been a way of life for Montanans longer than the state has existed. It's undergone changes, and developments, but despite the new tools, and the new legislature, the spirit has remained the same. One of Montana's first ranchers, a man who became a pioneer in ranching, of all things, sheep, was Henry Sieben.


Sieben didn't come from money, or have any education, but he knew enough to cut hay with a scythe, which was how he started his career in 1865. He worked his way to freighting goods from Utah to Montana mining camps with oxen. He and his brother Leonard started to buy worn out oxen from the men they worked for, and free ranged them. The most spectacular part of Sieben's rise to the top of the Ranching heap, is that he didn't acquire his first land holdings until twenty years after he had begun ranching. By this time he had already developed a reputation as one of Montana's most successful ranchers. 

Sieben slowly began to buy out small surrounding ranches, and hired the old owners on in a show of support.  He turned to sheep ranching in the 1870's, and became the owner of the largest flock in Montana. His first ranch, along the Smith River, was traded out for a ranch near Lewiston, which he eventually traded for two ranches near Cascade and Little Prickly Pear Peak. He used this as his home base to start the Sieben Livestock Company, still owned and operated today by his descendants. Just before his death in 1937, Sieben was included in the Montana Cowboy Hall of Fame, and remains there to this day. 




Montana is a great place to visit, but an even better place to live. To learn more about becoming a part of the Montana Experience, contact Tom Clark (406) 581 2829, drop me an e-mail at tom@realestator.net, or visit my site: http://tomsclark.yourkwagent.com/atj/user/HomePageGetAction.do

Need something to do in Bozeman? Check out http://realestator.blogspot.com/